Frama-C-discuss mailing list archives

This page gathers the archives of the old Frama-C-discuss archives, that was hosted by Inria's gforge before its demise at the end of 2020. To search for mails newer than September 2020, please visit the page of the new mailing list on Renater.

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Frama-c-discuss] Semantics of \valid

Hello Boris,

Le mer. 10 juin 2009 13:55:35 CEST,
"Hollas Boris (CR/AEY1)" <Boris.Hollas at> a ?crit :

> Consider an array a[n], n >= 0. Then, for integers l,r we have
> \valid(a+(l..r))  \neq  \valid_range(a,l,r)  (*)
> because
> \valid(a+(-1..-2)  =  \valid(\empty)  =  true
> but
> \valid_range(a,-1,-2)  =  \offset_min(p) <= -1 \land \offset_max(p) >= -2  =  false

You're right that both predicates are not equivalent (and that it is
quite ugly), but \valid_range(a,-1,-2) is not always false. Namely, with

int a[3];
int main() {
int* p=&a[2];
//@ assert \valid_range(p,-1,-2);
return 0;

the assertion is true: we have \offset_min(p) = -2, \offset_max(p) = 0
\valid_range(p,-1,-2) <==> \offset_min(p) <= -1 && \offset_max(p) >= -2
                      <==> -2 <= -1 && 0 >= -2 <==> \true
On the other hand, \valid_range(p,0,-1) is false.

BTW, I've summed up a lenghtier answer to your bug report in the wiki:

> \valid(s) holds if and only if s \ne \empty and dereferencing any p \in s is safe
> \valid_range(a,i,j) = \offset_min(p) <= i \land \offset_max(p) >= j \land i <= j

In fact, the definition given by the jessie plugin of \valid_range is
not exactly the informal one which existed before ACSL was published,
which was roughly \forall integer i; l <= i <= r ==> \valid(a+i). I'd
rather be in favor of keeping the definition of \valid as it is now,
without making a particular case for the empty set, and adapting the one
of \valid_range, which is definitively broken. In
terms of \offset_min and \offset_max, this could give
\valid_range(a,l,r) <==> 
  (l<=r ==> \offset_min(a) <= l && \offset_max(a) >= r)

Best regards,
E tutto per oggi, a la prossima volta.